Top Shelf Pizza in Honeoye

They have great pizza and pasta. The wings are awesome

Very good pizza would go back

Great slices!

Enjoyed the pizza

Food was delivered fish fry was large, hot and crispy but French fries were cold and soggy. Food is great 99.9% of the times I have ordered. Staff is friendly and helpful. I highly recommend this place.

Good hot wings.

Always fast and friendly. They use fresh mushrooms!

Great food!Awesome service and friendly people.

Pizza is not great. Almost always have a mistake on every order. Wings are dry and tough.Called asked for wings well done extra saucy. Got there to pick up order and there were basically no sauce on them. When I went in and asked for a few cups of sauce the demanded the charge me for the sauce. Which normally there would be no issue but I already asked for extra and am presuming I already paid for it but they did not offer or provide an itemized receipt. I will never again eat at top shelf due to pour and rude customer service and meh food which is over priced.

It was good, but the slices were very thick. If I liked thick pizza, it would have received a five star! Good flavor and very reasonably priced for sure!

First time ordering from Top Shelf and was not disappointed! Pizza and wings were awesome and delivered still hot. Would highly recommend.

Not to bad! What nice surprise

The food was tolerable taste wise, but there was a short black hair in my sub.

Great food and good people I eat there every time I'm in town

I always stop at Top Shelf when I'm in the area. Pizza is the BEST and their wings are excellent as well.

Best pizza and wings ever 👌

Delicious wraps and homemade chips. Will go again!

Great pizza and wings and good price and friendly employees

When i say this is the best pizza i habe ever had, i mean it!!!! The large roni pizza is about 4$ more expensive then other places but i promise its for a reason. It is truely TOP SHELF. i drive 40 min out to pick up this pizza and will continue to do so. Anyone who gives a bad review truely must have went during training or an off day. But i personally have NEVER had a bad experience.

Excellent pizza! Best in the area by far!!

Usually pretty good, but tonight was bad. 1 hour delivery time turned into an hour and 45 minutes. Pizza was cold. Wings were overcooked and very dry. When I called to find out where delivery was, person answering didn't have a clue. We work hard for our money and this $30.00 was a waste.

Delivery person was very late delivering our pizza and 2 dozen wings. They did not have change. We had to give the deliverer an 8 dollar tip. Also, the pizza and the wings were cold and we could not get a discount on our cold meal or future discount. Apparently its "against their policy"!!! Sorry Top Shelf, but you just lost a customer.

The best pizza I've had in years! Extensive menu, great prices.

This is 1 of the best pizza shops in town. Thanks for the best service and food, always hot and on time.

Terrible pizza. Crust is flavorless, it needs salt or something. I always eat my crust but threw this out. The cheese was so thick you choked on it and was a terrible flavor. The sauce was so minimal that you couldn't taste it. We ended up throwing away 2 pizzas.

Best pizza in town hands down

Great primo pizza and courteous staff!

Long time customer. Never had a single problem. Great food for a great price.

Great service

Their food is great and the menu is great, but their customer service leaves something to be desired. I ordered a cheeseburger plate, and they gave me a hamburger plate. When I got home, I didn't think it was worth going back for a couple pieces of cheese. I called expecting to at least get credit for the extra amount I payed for the cheese, but they wouldn't do anything unless I came back and got a new one. I placed an order for delivery, and called an hour and a half later when they hadn't shown up yet. They came half an hour later, and charged full price despite the fact that I had waited two hours for my order to arrive (and I live a mile away from the store). Also, the girl who typically answers the phone is rather rude. However, like I mentioned previously, their food is very good so I continue to order from them. This would be a five star review if their customer service was better.

Just tasted a half pepperoni half sausage pizza that we picked up at Top Shelf Pizza Honeoye....you guys are THE Best! Nice amount of sauce with great tasting toppings.We also love your crust.We try other places in region,but keep coming back to you!Keep up the great work!

Stopped by here passing by with friends after a hike. I'm a manager at a pizzeria in Rochester and consume a lot of pizza. With that said this might be the best slices of pizza I've ever ordered from any pizzeria. The chicken bacon ranch and cheese slices I got were absolutely amazing. I will definitely be stopping here whenever I'm in the area.

Pizza is good, but service isn't very friendly. Have had a few mistakes, but they've always taken care of it for us. If counter people were just a bit friendlier it would be a much better experience.

Great vacation food.We ordered the usual chicken wings and pizza, and are always a little nervous when we try a new place. But to our surprise the food was delicious and the service was fast and my teenage boys are happy. What more can you ask for

Had the seafood platter. Very yummy. It was delivered hot. Shrimp was tender. Clam strips werent rubbery. Fish was also very tasty. Staff pleasant and couteous. I recommend Top Shelf highly.

Everytime we get top shelf it is delicious.

Great pizza and wings, great customer service 10/10.

Quick Service and good food

Always good. Super friendly delivery drivers.

I was passing thru this town and thought this was a credible pizza place. Rather it being worse than than a arcade pizza not friendly staff and messed up my order. The crust was as big their sub I would have rather had a frozen pizza Would not recommend.

Great Pizza and good service

If you're looking for a solid pie in the Honeoye Lake area, you can't go wrong with Top Shelf Pizza. I highly encourage you to stop in if you're in the area, especially if you're staying at one of the many lake houses!

Very good subs great calzone not a fan of the red sauce

They are very good. Love it there!

Was told delivery up to 10 miles. I live 8.5 and they refuse to deliver. Thanks nick for the bad business

Unfriendly staff,liked the pizza ( although not much to compare to in town). Customer service and care lacking! Last experience, pizza not cooked, delivery late,called manager asked for a credit.Was told not their policy to give credit. Said he would cook another pizza and it would take 45 minutes. It was later in evening and I said it was too late. Wouldn't budge,so they lost a customer and I let other people know about my experience. It's not just about making a decent pizza, so I haven't been back since

We get pizza, wings and more from here about once a month. They have a huge menu. Food is very consistent, always hot and all very good. Tons of toppings on the pizzas. Delivery is pretty quick. It’s our go-to spot in town.

They have good pizza and good food. Nice people.

Pretty good pizza friendly people.

Love the chicken wing pizza!! So good!!